2:4 - Thor vs. Martian Manhunter

[UMPIRE]

SEASON 2, ROUND 4

Thor

Slot: The teams OH SHIT! button

Season Wins: 1

Season Losses: 0

Fantasy Team Page

Read more about Thor at Wikipedia

Official Site: Marvel

 

Martian Manhunter

Slot: The teams OH SHIT! button

Season Wins: 1

Season Losses: 0

Fantasy Team Page

Read more about Martian Manhunter at Wikipedia

Official Site: DC Comics

 

Battle Terrain

Combat Terrain: Pandora Night

 

[Fox]

Hum.  Interesting.

[Guest bigballerju]

These two are hard enough already to determine who would win in their normal states. At their most powerful? Yeah I am undecided. 

[Guest sithisson]

Coin flip? Really going to have to have the two team creators work the audience for a clear vote as there are so many ways to think on this.

[Guest thanosisawesome]

Martian Manhunter wins here. Both have relatively equal physicals. I think that MM's telepathy puts him over Thor. Thor does have a certain resistance, but this is the guy who subjugated Despero.

[Fox]

Martian Manhunter wins here. Both have relatively equal physicals. I think that MM's telepathy puts him over Thor. Thor does have a certain resistance, but this is the guy who subjugated Despero.

Just blue skying here, but could Thor set the whole Jungle terrain ablaze with his lightning bolts and trigger Manhunter's physiological fire phobia?

[corvette1710]

He certainly could, but I don't think that's how Thor tends to fight. If he were to, he might win, but otherwise, my vote would go to MM.

[Guest thanosisawesome]

Just blue skying here, but could Thor set the whole Jungle terrain ablaze with his lightning bolts and trigger Manhunter's physiological fire phobia?

I'm fairly certain that Manhunter is no longer afflicted by said phobia.

[xLEGACYx]

I'm fairly certain that Manhunter is no longer afflicted by said phobia.

currently it doesnt actually hurt him but he does have a phobia.  Recently he said in JLA that the fire doesnt hurt but he reacts the same from an internal phobia.

[Guest bigballerju]

Except for the fact this is the oh shit slot so the most powerful version is Rune King Thor. Keep that in mind.

[Guest thanosisawesome]

I still don't think that Thor couldn't withstand a concentrated telepathic assault. 

[comic_book_fan]

rune king thor is on another level than manhunter he wins.

[Fox]

rune king thor is on another level than manhunter he wins.

I need to create some kind of CBUB Database character version system so it's easier to work with and select different versions of the same character I think.

[Guest Incredible Hulk]

I need to create some kind of CBUB Database character version system so it's easier to work with and select different versions of the same character I think.

Yah, even though it might take a while to creat (although I'm not an expert so it might not take that long) this would be great addition to the database. People could just choose the character and its version. It would also help clean up the database some, especially in the comics section.

[Guest sirmethos]

It's only an issue with the new Drafts.  With the Rated Matches, the version of the character is generally specified via the setup.

[Guest thanosisawesome]

Rune King Thor is against the rules, so this would be most powerful Thor that isn't Rune King.

[Indolent]

If it's Rune King Thor, Martian Manhunter doesn't really have a chance.

[comic_book_fan]

Rune King Thor is against the rules, so this would be most powerful Thor that isn't Rune King.

still god blast wins.

[Guest Hayesmeister5651]

Would the god blast have any effect on an intangible Manhunter?

[comic_book_fan]

Would the god blast have any effect on an intangible Manhunter?

I don't know it didn't save apocalypse  I think the argument is thor has experience over intangible opponents.

[Guest bigballerju]

For the oh shit slot Rune King isn't against the rules if that is his most powerful version. If it isn't then yea it wouldn't be used. MM loses. Thor at his most powerful is going to have more abilities at his disposal to beat Martian Manhunter with.

[Guest thanosisawesome]

Fox said no Skyfather level entities, which is basically exactly Rune King Thor.

[Guest Dr. Pymp(mex)]

So then not at their most powerful?

Either way Thor wins after. 3 issue mini series

[Guest thanosisawesome]

So then not at their most powerful?

Either way Thor wins after. 3 issue mini series

No he doesn't. When has he resisted a telepath as powerful as MM?

[Guest bigballerju]

Odinforce Thor can still be used here and that Thor still has abilities that would give him the win against Martian Manhunter.