13:2 - Elvira (Mistress of the Dark) vs. Jack Skellington

[UMPIRE]

SEASON 13, ROUND 2

Elvira (Mistress of the Dark)

Slot: The Team's Horror Icon
Season Wins: 0
Season Losses: 0
Fantasy Team Page
Read more about Elvira (Mistress of the Dark) at this Wiki
Official Site: Cassandra Peterson

Jack Skellington

Slot: The Team's Christmas Themed Character
Season Wins: 0
Season Losses: 0
Fantasy Team Page
Read more about Jack Skellington at this Wiki
Official Site: Touchstone Pictures

Battle Terrain
Christmas Vs. Halloween: Role Reversal

[Peypeypeypey]

I feel like these two already have very similar jobs. Jack is highly competent at pretty much everything he sets his mind to and is already a global icon, but so is Elvira. 

[Fox]

Jack Skellington is representing here in the "Christmas Themed Character" slot.  That's important because Jack Skellington sucked at Christmas.

Does Elvira suck at Christmas? No! She's great at giving people exactly what they want.

Can Jack Skellington do Elvira's job and keep an audience watching B-grade horror films? Probably not as well, no.

[Macklemore]

1 hour ago, Fox said:

Can Jack Skellington do Elvira's job and keep an audience watching B-grade horror films? Probably not as well, no.

Oh please, Elvira's "job" is to look pretty. Jack not only has a pretty rabid fanbase based on his look entirely (unfortunately), he also has an amazing personality to boot. This is something anyone that has seen these movies can agree on. He even has an amazing singing voice!

Yes, I do believe that Jack can be a better host. His charisma is already much higher than Elvira, but even if he just needs to sit there and look pretty, people would still tune in. Elvira on the other hand needs to introduce Christmas to a town of rabid Halloween enjoyers while also getting the best of Oogie Boogie. She fails this one.

[DSkillz]

Jack may not do all that great in some Christmas-themed challenges, but I think he has the edge here. He has an interesting Santa costume, and some people may actually be into the scary gifts he gives out. 

Elvira would do pretty well as a sexy "Pumpkin Queen", but I don't think she can outdo Jack at his own schtick.  

[UMPIRE]

Match Final Results

Elvira (Mistress of the Dark): 7
Jack Skellington: 9