10:5 - Catherine Tramell vs. Evelyn O'Connell

[UMPIRE]

SEASON 10, ROUND 5

Catherine Tramell

Slot: The Team's Man Eater
Season Wins: 1
Season Losses: 0
Fantasy Team Page
Read more about Catherine Tramell at this Wiki
Official Site: Sony Pictures

Evelyn O'Connell

Slot: The Team's Man Eater
Season Wins: 1
Season Losses: 0
Fantasy Team Page
Read more about Evelyn O'Connell at this Wiki
Official Site: Universal Pictures

Battle Terrain
Romance Scenario: Sherlock Holmes

[Fox]

The question being, what would make the most entertaining romance?

Sherlock and the clever yet clumsy museum expert Evelyn would be a nice romance.  Possibly a heartwarming romance.  It's a romance I'm sure I would enjoy watching the dynamics of. It is a safe choice.

However, a Sherlock romance with psycho and serial killer Catherine Tramell would be edge of your seat viewing.  Naturally, it ends with Catherine caught and headed for the big house.  But the twists and turns along the way in this whodunit would be glorious.

 

[Ultimate-Man]

I can definitely see that Evelyn will be the perfect woman for Sherlock than Catherine who is a criminal.

[DSkillz]

The change-up of how the romantic picks match up definitely changes the dynamic of how to debate with them. 

Gotta think on this one.

[Pizzaguy2995]

So I’m guessing this is the BBC Sherlock? In this case I think we actually saw how this love triangle would go down in the show itself: Evelyn would be the Molly in this scenario, she’s nice and means well but Holmes would be hard press to even remember her name, cause unless you have something to do with his case, your not on his radar. Catherine would be Irene, the deadly, cunning, and manipulative villainess that Holmes would be utterly obsessed with, more so her methods and criminal success then with her looks.

Again, Evelyn like would be nice if your looking for a nice, safe Barbie and Ken romance. But Sherlock ain’t Ken and he isn’t looking for a Barbie. And I would think any hardcore Sherlock fan would know that the love interests that produces the most entertainment are the femme fatales!

[broadwaybeyonder]

Don't know either character besides Catherine's picture, but I went with her anyway.  

[UMPIRE]

Match Final Results

Catherine Tramell: 5
Evelyn O'Connell: 4