Rumble 20644 A-Wing Starfighter vs. ARC 170 vs. Enterprise-E

[leroypowell3]

Next batch of new characters making themselves known.

The Enterprise E has been warped to an uncharted area of space.

They witness a battle taking place between swarms of small fighters.

Both forces while still fighting each other attack then huge new ship.

Who emerges victorious?

[Callisto]

Learn More About
A-Wing Starfighter
Read more about A-Wing Starfighter at Wikipedia
Official Site: Lucasfilm Links: Wikipedia

ARC 170
Read more about ARC 170 at Wikipedia
Official Site: Lucasfilm Links: Wikipedia

Enterprise-E
Read more about Enterprise-E at Wikipedia
Official Site: Paramount Links: Wikipedia

[Mercenaryblade]

Enterprise E takes this, the fighters weapons won't get past even their navigational shields, and if they were a threat the Enterprise has been shown to hit small targets with pinpoint accuracy. Phasers have 360 degrees of fire, and torpedo spreads can be detonated without hitting a target which would be perfect against swarms of small targets. 

The Enterprise could even just beam the pilots and crew out of their vessels and into the brig without their weapons. Picard will likely have a sit down with the leaders and they all come to an understanding and go their opposite ways ti triumphant orchestral music. 

But the Enterprise is also likely to just not get involved. After all this is a local dispute that doesn't concern them. 

If it comes down to A-Wings vs ARC 170s, I have to vote A-wing they're a much more advanced craft than the 170s. This would be like a Vietnam era F8 Crusader fighting a modernized F16. The biggest advantage the ARC's have is better shielding and firepower, but I don't think it will be enough to net them a win. 

Basically no matter how we slice it the big E wins.  

 

[leroypowell3]

On 6/6/2024 at 10:06 PM, Mercenaryblade said:

Enterprise E takes this, the fighters weapons won't get past even their navigational shields, and if they were a threat the Enterprise has been shown to hit small targets with pinpoint accuracy. Phasers have 360 degrees of fire, and torpedo spreads can be detonated without hitting a target which would be perfect against swarms of small targets. 

The Enterprise could even just beam the pilots and crew out of their vessels and into the brig without their weapons. Picard will likely have a sit down with the leaders and they all come to an understanding and go their opposite ways ti triumphant orchestral music. 

But the Enterprise is also likely to just not get involved. After all this is a local dispute that doesn't concern them. 

If it comes down to A-Wings vs ARC 170s, I have to vote A-wing they're a much more advanced craft than the 170s. This would be like a Vietnam era F8 Crusader fighting a modernized F16. The biggest advantage the ARC's have is better shielding and firepower, but I don't think it will be enough to net them a win. 

Basically no matter how we slice it the big E wins.  

 

Yep.

[Callisto]

MATCH SCORE
A-Wing Starfighter: 0
ARC 170: 0
Enterprise-E: 6