I'm not going to respond in depth because I just don't really want to get into the weeds of what Michael Scott as a boss, because it super doesn't matter. We're not looking for a boss, or anyone to lead the company out of trouble, we're looking for a mascot. A symbol for the company to rally behind. Michael's flaws are a lot more of problem in that context, and his opponent is a much more tried and true mascot, so he should win. Honestly, Michael shouldn't even really be in this category in my opinion