Rumble 20089 Negan vs. John Winchester

[Culwych1]

In the aftermath of a cataclysmic monster apocalypse, the world is in ruins and countless billions are dead. The world is now one of brutal survival and tribal mentality, and it is in the wreckage that leaders (who bear an uncanny resemblance to each other) are forged. 

Best of three scenarios: 

1. Who creates the best camp at surviving a monster apocalypse; leading 100 people each surviving for 1 year in the same conditions and same equipment (guns, ammo, knives, swords, bats etc.). 

2. The camps become aware of each other, and realise that a fight for resources is the only option. Which camp will be victorious at the end of the day - any means necessary. 

3. In the aftermath of this clash of camps, the two leaders find each other in a clearing of a forest. As they stare at each other under the silent trees, a fight to the death will determine their fate!

[Callisto]

Learn More About
Negan
Read more about Negan at Wikipedia
Official Site: Image Links: Wikipedia Walking Dead Wiki Comicvine

John Winchester
Read more about John Winchester at Wikipedia
Official Site: CW TV Links: Wikipedia John Winchester - Wiki Winchester Journals

[Pizzaguy2995]

I see John winning all three scenarios pretty handily. In terms of combat he’ll hard stomp Negan, he’s faced down creatures and deities that’d make Negan wet himself. But even in terms of leadership I give the edge to John because ultimately he trained two of the greatest supernatural hunters the world has ever seen, put him in charge of training an army and they’ll be unstoppable! Negan meanwhile only seems to be able to attract sociopaths and cowardly bullies to his side.

[Callisto]

MATCH SCORE
Negan: 0
John Winchester: 4